Difference between revisions of "2010 Winter Project Week Congealing Testing Debugging"
| (3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
<gallery> | <gallery> | ||
Image:z15-aff.png|Affine registration result on subject 15. | Image:z15-aff.png|Affine registration result on subject 15. | ||
| − | Image:z15-b8.png| | + | Image:z15-b8.png|B-spline 8 registration result on subject 15. |
| − | Image: z15-b16.png| | + | Image: z15-b16.png|B-spline 16 registration result on subject 15. |
| − | Image: z15-b32.png| | + | Image: z15-b32.png|B-spline 32 registration result on subject 15. |
</gallery> | </gallery> | ||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
<h3>Approach, Plan</h3> | <h3>Approach, Plan</h3> | ||
| − | Initial issue: congealing does not work with recent ITK. The goal is to figure out where the problem is. The plan is to run existing tests from sandbox and test on 26-subject FA dataset | + | Initial issue: congealing does not work with recent ITK. The goal is to figure out where the problem is. The plan is to run existing tests from sandbox and also test on 26-subject FA dataset, and debug. |
</div> | </div> | ||
| Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
We found that the multiresolution B splines may have a bug as results were "smeared". Luis suggests the optimizer may not be using the correct size scale. However the initial size 8 grid seems to work well. See above image results. | We found that the multiresolution B splines may have a bug as results were "smeared". Luis suggests the optimizer may not be using the correct size scale. However the initial size 8 grid seems to work well. See above image results. | ||
| − | Some congealing tests initially crashed with recent ITK. We are running against the backwards compatible ITK now. | + | Some congealing tests initially crashed with recent ITK. We are running against the backwards compatible ITK now to see if Serdar's original tests pass. (So far 36/96 have passed including ones that failed with recent ITK.) |
</div> | </div> | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
Latest revision as of 18:56, 8 January 2010
Home < 2010 Winter Project Week Congealing Testing Debugging
Affine registration result on subject 15.
B-spline 8 registration result on subject 15.
B-spline 16 registration result on subject 15.
B-spline 32 registration result on subject 15.
Key Investigators
- BWH: Lauren O'Donnell
- Kitware: Luis Ibanez
Objective
Test and debug congealing registration implementation in ITK (in NAMIC Sandbox).
Approach, Plan
Initial issue: congealing does not work with recent ITK. The goal is to figure out where the problem is. The plan is to run existing tests from sandbox and also test on 26-subject FA dataset, and debug.
Progress
We got congealing to run without errors or crashes. However more work would be needed for it to be compatible with recent changes/improvements in ITK.
We found the following backwards-compatible flag is needed to run congealing: ITK_USE_CENTERED_PIXEL_COORDINATES_CONSISTENTLY:BOOL=OFF.
We tested the code with existing tests from Serdar and also on a 26-subject FA dataset. We debugged initial crashing problems and patched a bug assuming all input images had the same size. To use this code in its current version however it may be advisable to pad all imput images to the same dimensions.
We found that the multiresolution B splines may have a bug as results were "smeared". Luis suggests the optimizer may not be using the correct size scale. However the initial size 8 grid seems to work well. See above image results.
Some congealing tests initially crashed with recent ITK. We are running against the backwards compatible ITK now to see if Serdar's original tests pass. (So far 36/96 have passed including ones that failed with recent ITK.)
